Coucnil Banner Image

Council Meetings

Development Plan Meeting Meeting 16 May 2016 Agenda


Date:
16/05/2016 16:00
Location:
Council Chamber

Headed Items

H-I (1)

Submitted by:
Landuse Planning & Transportation
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Chief Executive’s Report and Presentation

H-I (2)

Submitted by:
Landuse Planning & Transportation
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Environmental Assessment of the Proposed Motions

H-I (3)

Submitted by:
Landuse Planning & Transportation
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Resolution to make the South Dublin County Council Development Plan 2016 – 2022 (end of meeting) 

Core Strategy

Housing

Motions

Mot (1)

Submitted by:
Councillor S. Holland
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

SLO H3 SL01 to have the following text reinstated:

"Any future development should have regard to the boundaries with and the protection of the existing amenity and function of Edmondstown golf course"

Co-sponsored by Cllr Paula Donovan and Cllr Deirdre O'Donovan

Mot (2)

Submitted by:
Councillor A-M. Dermody
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Material Alteration Ref. Chapter 2 - No.3

That provision of a strip of land 30 metres in width be included in this Development Plan, along the boundary of Edmundstown Golf Club.  In so allowing this would be in keeping with SLO 91 and SLO 113 of last two Development Plans of 2004 & 2010. By being specific as to the size of the area ensures that the objective as affirmed in both of the previous Development Plans 2004 & 2010  is protected and also that the use of this 30 metre strip be restricted to communal open space.

Mot (3)

Submitted by:
Councillor W. Lavelle
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

That this Council declines to accept the first part of the Chief Executive's recommendation in relation to Material Alteration Ref. Chapter 2 - No. 4 and agrees to retain H8 Objective 6 as displayed.

Community Infrastructure

Motions

Mot (4)

Submitted by:
Councillor L. O'Toole
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Cllr. Liona O'Toole , Cllr Paul Gogarty, Cllr. Guss O'Connell

(replaces motion 49407)

To add the following line at the end of C7 SLO 1:

The new sports facility will ensure that sufficient capacity is built in to provide space for sports equipment from local clubs including equipment required for users with special needs.

Mot (5)

Submitted by:
Councillor R. McMahon
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

With Reference 3.11.0 - With regard to the reference to change in text to what the Minister announced pre-election to refer to proposed Post Primary School in Firhouse, I propose that the original text stands and to leave the reference to Knocklyon/Ballycullen/Firhouse area. 

Economic Development & Tourism

Urban Centres & Retailing

Motions

Mot (6)

Submitted by:
Councillor P. Gogarty
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Motion in the name of Cllrs Paul Gogarty Liona O'Toole and Guss O'Connell:

Amend R6 Objective 3 to read: "To support and facilitate the development of new District Centres of an appropriate urban scale at Adamstown and Clonburris in accordance with approved Planning Schemes which should provide a sustainable retail mix including department stores and shopping centres that facilitates walking, cycling and use of public transport and reduces car journeys outside the SDZ for many retail needs.

Transport & Mobility

Motions

Mot (7)

Submitted by:
Councillor R. McMahon
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

To remove the objective from the plan under Table 6.6 Medium to Long term Objectives the reference to a new bridge from Firhouse to N81 due to its' unsuitability for many reasons at this location

Mot (8)

Submitted by:
Councillor K. Mahon
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

That CEO's Material Alteration Chapter 6 No. 7 (to re-instate the Proposed Road cutting Dodder Valley from Firhouse to the N81) be removed from the Development Plan.

Mot (9)

Submitted by:
Councillor R. McMahon
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

To remove the objective from the plan under Table 6.6 Medium to Long term Objectives the reference to a new bridge from Bohernabreena Road to Kiltipper Road due to its' unsuitability for many reasons at this location

Infrastructure & Environmental Quality

Motions

Mot (10)

Submitted by:
Councillor W. Lavelle
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Co-sponsored by Cllr V. Casserly

That this Council declines to accept the Chief Executive's recommendation in relation to Material Alteration Ref. Chapter 7 - No.12 and agrees to retain IE9 Objective 6 as displayed.

Mot (11)

Submitted by:
Councillor W. Lavelle
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Co-sponsored by Cllr V. Casserly

That this Council declines to accept the Chief Executive's recommendation in relation to Material Alteration Ref. Chapter 7 - No.12 and agrees to retain IE9 Objective 6 as displayed, subject to the following modification:

That the following wording be added to the end of IE9 Objective 6: “South Dublin County Council shall, during the lifetime of this plan, facilitate a public consultation and comprehensive review of the land-use planning framework governing the future operation of Weston Aerodrome; and arising from this consultation and review shall recommend any variations to the plan as may be considered appropriate for consideration by the elected members.”

 

Mot (12)

Submitted by:
Councillor W. Lavelle
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Co-sponsored by Cllr V. Casserly

That this Council declines to accept the Chief Executive's recommendation in relation to Material Alteration Ref. Chapter 7 - No.13 and agrees to retain IE9 Objective 7 as displayed.

Green Infrastructure

Heritage, Architectural Conservation & Landscapes

Motions

Mot (13)

Submitted by:
Councillor R. McMahon
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

To remove the words "for use by local farmers" and to include the wording under HCL 9 Objective 7 "....and to encourage the grazing of such areas by local farmers, which would include the provision of cattle grids on the roads leading down from the commonage"

Energy

Motions

Mot (14)

Submitted by:
Councillor P. Gogarty
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Motion Cllrs Paul Gogarty, Liona O'Toole, Guss O'Connell

Amend E2 Objective 6 to read: To ensure all new public buildings (eg Council buildings, school buildings, hospitals, health centres, community centres, sports facilities, libraries, Garda stations etc) are designed to include PV solar panels for electricity generation/storage and/or water heating so as to reduce energy costs, minimise carbon emissions and reduce our dependence on imported fossil fuels.

Mot (15)

Submitted by:
Councillor P. Gogarty
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Motion Cllrs P Gogarty, L O'Toole, G O'Connell

Insert E2 Objective 7 to read:

To actively promote, where feasibly practical and viable, the provision of PV solar panels in new housing and apartment builds, for electricity generation/storage and/or water heating, so as to reduce the long term energy/heating costs of residents living in such dwellings, to minimise carbon emissions and to reduce Ireland's dependency on imported energy derived from fossil fuels.

Mot (16)

Submitted by:
Councillor P. Gogarty
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Motion Cllr P Gogarty, Cllr L O'Toole, Cllr G O'Connell

Insert E2 Objective 8 to read: To ensure, where feasibly practical and viable, the provision of green roofs for all new public buildings (Council buildings, school buildings, hospitals, community centres, sports facilities, libraries, Garda stations etc), to assist in flood alleviation, insulation and improved biodiversity, and to actively promote these measures where appropriate in new commercial and industrial buildings.

Mot (17)

Submitted by:
Councillor P. Gogarty
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Motion Cllrs P Gogarty, G O'Connell, L O'Toole

To amend E11 Objective 1 to read: To work in conjunction with EirGrid to prioritise the undergrounding of the 220kv power line between Foxborough and the County boundary, including in the Balgaddy and Ronanstown areas.

Implementation

Miscellaneous

Mapping

Motions

Mot (18)

Submitted by:
Councillor E. Higgins
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

That the Council retain the EE zoning at Moneenalion Commons Upper and Collegelands as per the zoning in the Draft Development Plan and; that the Specific Local Objective IE3SL0:1 be retained for the subject lands  (i.e. to require the preparation of a site and catchment specific Flood Risk Assessment and Mitigation Strategy, prepared by a qualified person(s), to be submitted with any proposal for development on these ‘EE’ zoned lands”).

The rationale for the subject EE zoning on the subject lands was provided during the preparation of the Draft Development Plan and that rationale still stands.  A detailed submission on the proposed material amendments has been made by John Spain Associates on behalf of MLEU Dublin  Ltd.  This submission sets out a detailed rationale including a full Justification Test for Development Plans for the retention of the EE zoning and SLO IE3SLO:1 on the subject lands.  I refer specifically to the conclusions of this submission set out in Section 4 of the submission which I believe sets out clearly the rationale for the EE zoning and provides a reasonable justification for the retention of the EE zoning and the specific local objective IE3SLO:1.

Map: 

https://picasaweb.google.com/112464768887449628770/6278336393648838433?authuser=0&feat=directlink

Mot (19)

Submitted by:
Councillor K. Egan
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

That the Council retain the EE zoning at Moneenalion Commons Upper and Collegelands as per the zoning in the Draft Development Plan and; that the Specific Local Objective IE3SL0:1 be retained for the subject lands  (i.e. to require the preparation of a site and catchment specific Flood Risk Assessment and Mitigation Strategy, prepared by a qualified person(s), to be submitted with any proposal for development on these ‘EE’ zoned lands”).

The rationale for the subject EE zoning on the subject lands was provided during the preparation of the Draft Development Plan and that rationale still stands.  A detailed submission on the proposed material amendments has been made by John Spain Associates on behalf of MLEU Dublin  Ltd.  This submission sets out a detailed rationale including a full Justification Test for Development Plans for the retention of the EE zoning and SLO IE3SLO:1 on the subject lands.  I refer specifically to the conclusions of this submission set out in Section 4 of the submission which I believe sets out clearly the rationale for the EE zoning and provides a reasonable justification for the retention of the EE zoning and the specific local objective IE3SLO:1.

Mot (20)

Submitted by:
Councillor M. Murphy
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Co-sponsored by Cllr B. Leech & Cllr K. Mahon

Material alteration 07-08 relating to zoning lands at Baldonnell which are identified as being at risk of flooding and also identified as not being a strategic site in terms of its location be maintained as displayed.

Mot (21)

Submitted by:
Councillor L. O'Toole
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Cllr. Liona O'Toole , Cllr Guss O'Connell, Cllr. Paul Gogarty

To add the following line to Ref: MA M07 (page 141 material alterations)

Land use Zoning Alteration at Mount Bellew, Lucan – Residential (RES) zoning to Open Space (OS) zoning with an objective ‘To preserve and provide for open space and recreational amenities’ including a safe drop-off / turning facility / parking zone for both school traffic and any future community buildings.

Mot (22)

Submitted by:
Councillor B. Bonner
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

That the zoning of the site next to the Green Isle Hotel at Boot Road / Old Naas Road would be reverted to (OS)  Open Space, with a Specific Local Objective to facilitate and extension to the Hotel for it's existing activities.

Mot (23)

Submitted by:
Councillor F. Timmons
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Re Material Alteration - .M12 - zoning of lands adjacent to Green Isle Hotel from Open Space (OS) to Enterprise and Employment (EE) - That this is not granted and that the Open Space (0S) is kept with a specific Local Objective to facilitate an extension to the Hotel for Office space and Hotel Business.  

Mot (24)

Submitted by:
Councillor F. Timmons
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

Re Material Alteration - .M12 - zoning of lands adjacent to Green Isle Hotel from Open Space (OS) to Enterprise and Employment (EE) - That this is not granted and that the Open Space (0S) is kept with a specific Local Objective to facilitate the retention of what is
remaining of the Old Naas Road wall.

Mot (25)

Submitted by:
Councillor E. Higgins
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

With reference to MA.M13 that the proposed change of zoning from F to EE, at the site next to the Green Isle Hotel on Boot Road, be subject to a Specific Local Objective that limits development at this site to an infill extension of the Hotel’s existing activities

Mot (26)

Submitted by:
Councillor K. Egan
Responsibility:
Brian Keaney

With reference to MA.M13 that the proposed change of zoning from F to EE, at the site next to the Green Isle Hotel on Boot Road, be subject to a Specific Local Objective that limits development at this site to an infill extension of the Hotel’s existing activities

A-Z of All Services